While I respect what you’re saying, music as a whole is so broad that I feel you could only make those kinds of arguments for certain styles of music.

For example, jazz is one notable exception where studio album tracks are pretty much recorded in one take without overdubs and are “live” from the studio. Improvising is essential to the music, and musicians interact with the crowd when live. The crowd response informs the notes bring played in a way that would not be possible in a studio.

Certain types of rock also benefit from live recordings, where mistakes and imprecisions convey a certain excitement to the sound!