• 0 Posts
  • 13 Comments
Joined 3 年前
cake
Cake day: 2023年7月2日

help-circle


  • Yes, it can be still hard to believe how rotten and degraded Putin’s army is, and how fast barely trained Moscovian soldiers die on the frontline. But there’s plenty of evidence to it: including reports that Moscovian air defense personnel is highly incompetent. You have probably seen numerous videos pointing to this fact, and many Ruscists wrote about this.

    How could this be otherwise, after decades of dedovschina and corruption? And even during WW II, when the army was much stronger, thousands of barely trained people were sent to die in meatwaves, and Moscow was on the verge of evacuation.






  • Well, it makes sense if you interpret both the Soviet Union and Russian Federation through the lense of state capitalism. IMHO, it’s the worst possible and most aggressive kind of capitalism, which does not have checks and balances. In modern Moscovia with its personalized mafia cleptocracy, it gets even worse than in the Soviet Union that operated on somewhat collective decision making. Hence the lawlessness, raider attacks and shootouts. And of course, aggression toward neighbouring states.



  • As a Ukrainian, I would say there is a grain of truth in what you say, with several important caveats.

    First, Moscovia already collapsed as a nation due to many centuries of imperial history. At least since the beginning of the 20th century, being Russian is not about nationality, it is about belonging to the Russian empire. This is the last extant empire in Europe, oppressing numerous nations, and it is inevitably going to break down like all the others.

    Interestingly, Moscovia started as a colony of the Kyiv Rus, and the history might repeat, but in a quite different manner. Since the empire is clearly inefficient, it will be gradually taken over by other more efficient states, albeit not by old style occupation. Plain occupation is impossible because of the huge territory.

    Somalia story gives clues on what is likely to happen next. Many years ago Somalia leadership wanted to restore a “great Somali” as an imperial revanchist project. Then it lost the war and broke down. Now neighbouring states have established orderly protectorates near their borders, while there’s still mayhem in the center of Somalia.

    Similarly, the EU, and Ukraine in particular, may support civil order in new protectorates on neighbouring territories, with a perspective of eventual EU expansion further East.