The draft law provides for joint civil liability for property damage during a protest. It would allow courts to order individual participants, including the parents of children who participated, to pay up to €10,000 in damages—or perform community service—whether or not the individual committed acts of violence or caused the damage.
People could be penalized simply for “knowingly” participating in an “unlawful assembly” (attroupement), defined in the French criminal code as “any gathering of people on a public highway or in a public place that is likely to disturb public order,” or for failing to disperse after the police issue orders for a second time. Legal commentators have said that the requirement for prior dispersal orders is not an effective safeguard, because such orders are in practice either not issued or are not sufficiently audible.
Being present during a protest considered an unlawful assembly, or failing to leave the area fast enough following police orders to disperse, could trigger severe financial consequences. The bill requires prosecutors to share suspects’ identities with prefects, the interior minister’s local representative, and local authorities so they can pursue damage claims in civil court, even if the prosecutor has decided not to pursue criminal charges.
The bill would allow criminal penalties of up to one year in prison and a €15,000 fine for organizers of banned protests, and six months in prison and a €7,500 fine for participants, or in some cases, a summary fine of €500 to avoid prosecution. Existing law allows six months in prison and a €7,500 fine only for protest organizers. Punishments can be doubled for people who cover their faces. The bill also gives prefects the power, without prior judicial oversight, to preemptively ban individuals from protests for 24 hours on the basis of police intelligence or evidence of repeated or serious violent behavior during the three preceding years.
When the protesters are on the right track, the rich assholes team up and try to stop the effective protest.
They would have also tried to pass a bill fining people that guillotine public officials, were it 250 years ago. That did not stop anyone from guillotining public officials.
Doubling down on police state is going to go very wrong.
I hate to bat for the Americans, but it’s hard to look at 21st century Europe and not think “damn, the First Amendment was a really good idea.”
Was it? Good in theory, it doesn’t guarantee free speech in a fascist police state that ignores all laws.
It does; even with a fascist trifecta Trump couldn’t actually do anything about people’s right to free speech and assembly. He certainly couldn’t pass a law saying they can’t do it.
Collective punishment sounds like a good way to get more riots, not peace.
Punishments can be doubled for people who cover their faces.
What I’m hearing is that covering your face is good and effective.
Eventually, the working class is going to have to rise up and kill their oppressors.
There is no other way.




