History Major. Cripple. Vaguely Left-Wing. In pain and constantly irritable.

  • 1.35K Posts
  • 680 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: March 24th, 2025

help-circle



























  • All identities are arbitrary though.

    For that matter, nationalism was *anti-*reactionary in its strongest period, in the 19th century.

    Nationalism is reactionary today because it is established, and anything already well-established is a target for reactionaries, who use concepts with pre-existing attachments to dupe useful idiots into thinking that the enemies of the reactionaries and the enemies of the establishment are one and the same. Nearly any period of significant political or cultural upheaval will show that simplistic narrative flies in the face of facts. But they aren’t targeting engaged, politically aware folk. They’re targeting people who are scared and don’t want to think about it too much.

    Not that nationalism is all that great to begin with. But it’s not particularly different than any other conception of identity.











  • What if I don’t believe in the inherent worth of human beings?

    What if I believe some people, like Nazis, are worth less than non-Nazi human beings?

    Ableism is bad. I’m just not sure that ‘inherent worth of human beings’ is the reason to oppose it. Some human beings, like Nazis, have qualities that legitimately reduce their worth. Other human beings, like the disabled, do not inherently have qualities that reduce their worth.

    The question is less about inherent worth of human beings, and more about what qualities are legitimate to judge a human being on.


  • Forgive me for bringing my favorite obsession into this, but I’m always reminded of Ancient Roman discourses on nature.

    Romans sometimes noted that such behaviors as ‘speech’ and ‘wearing clothes’ were unnatural. Rather than a criticism of these behaviors, it was only a casual observation - that which is natural and that which humans find useful are not always one and the same.

    Even if greed was human nature, to the exclusion of altruism, that would still not make it the best course of action to enable. Something many capitalist apologists seem to ‘forget’.